This Caldwell Lost and Found Peanut Butter Cup Halloween 2022 Robusto cigar is made in the Dominican Republic. Outside, you'll find an Undisclosed wrapper. Inside, the binder is Undisclosed, and the filler is Dominican, Peruvian. This is a Robusto Shaped Cigar with a length of 5.00 and a ring gauge of 50.

 They’re the cream of the crop. The crème de la crème. The best thing you can find in your kids’ Halloween buckets: peanut butter cups. No amount of them could satisfy your hunger for more. They’re a gift directly from the gods – smooth, buttery, chocolatey – and just about the most addictive substance right after crack cocaine.

They’re the destroyer of diets.
A calamity of calories.
And we’re about to eat a fat stack of them this Halloween, alongside this release from Caldwell’s Lost and Found line.

This is the Peanut Butter Cup cigar. And woe to the man or woman who pairs it with anything but a tall frosty glass of milk over ice (Kahlúa and vodka, too, please).

Caldwell has had many hits in this series. They’ve been all over the map – Pepper Cream Soda, Scooby Snax, One Night Stand – and that’s by design. The source of all stogies in this cornucopia of tobacco could be anywhere. It could be a shipment of cigars from a company that never made it to the loading dock. It could be a blend that needed to age and was forgotten. Or it could be something that didn’t fit the desired plan once production ramped up.

For whatever reason, some cigars get lost, and Robert Caldwell travels through Latin America and the Caribbean (lucky f***er!) trying to find them. If they pass the smoke test, they get sent along to us. Then he’s on to the next stop.

The Caldwell Lost and Found Peanut Butter Cup is the “found” cigar for Halloween 2022. He tells us that the stogie was initially rolled up in 2019, so it has some nice age. This suits the mostly Dominican filler leaf just fine. The wrapper is a milk chocolate Maduro that brings an earthy sweetness to the blend. Naturally, we can’t help but taste notes of peanuts, cocoa, and butter in the mix. But of course, there are also cigar aromas like leather and hints of spice you just won’t get in any PB cups from Reese’s. That’s fine. We love the flavor we’re getting out of this blend.

Puff away in the shadows and scare some kids this year. It’s tradition!

Please browse our selection of Caldwell Lost and Found Peanut Butter Cup Halloween 2022 cigars at your leisure.

• What are the flavors like?
o A hint of spice, nuts, cocoa, and leather.

• What’s the strength level?
o Medium.

• Who is this cigar for?
o Caldwell Lost and Found Peanut Butter Cup Halloween 2022 cigars are for adventurers of late fall who are willing to spark up anything without knowing its whole story.

• Will I want to smoke it to the nub?
o You’ll get distracted by buckets of candy, no doubt.

• What’s a good pairing with it?
o Could be a frosty milkshake or any pumpkin beer you’ve got in the fridge to clear out.

• What’s the best time/place to smoke this cigar?
o Ain’t it obvious? This one is for lighting on All Hallows’ Eve!

• Any flaws/downsides?
o Limited quantity